PSA or BGS: which one to choose?
Two grading companies, two grading logics, two markets. What really sets them apart when you have to choose.
Two ways of grading
PSA gives a single overall grade, from 1 to 10. It is simple to read and simple to compare: a PSA 9 is a PSA 9, everywhere.
BGS grades the four sub-criteria separately — centring, corners, edges, surface — then derives an overall grade from them. A card can therefore show a 9.5 overall with the detail of what kept it from a 10.
Liquidity, the real criterion
On the European market, PSA is the most traded reference: a PSA slab resells faster, and its price is easier to establish because there are more comparables.
BGS keeps a strong place among collectors chasing perfection — its black label, reserved for cards graded 10 on all four sub-criteria, is one of the most coveted objects in the hobby. But it is a narrower market.
The detail that counts: the subgrade
The detailed grading from BGS is a double-edged sword. On an excellent card it proves the quality point by point. On an average card it exposes the flaw precisely — where an overall PSA grade stays more discreet.
In practice
If the goal is to resell, or simply to have a grade everyone understands, PSA is the default choice, and it is the one Prismea submits to — at PSA Frankfurt.
If the goal is a collection piece whose perfection you want documented, BGS has an argument PSA does not.
In both cases the prior question stays the same: does this card deserve to be graded? The guide on card value answers that one.
Read next
What is my card worth? · Glossary
All guides · Updated on 14 August 2026